Sunday, June 16

Would California bridges withstand a direct hit? We asked professionals

Baltimore’s Francis Scott Key Bridge stood long shot of survival Tuesday when a freight ship rammed into it: Its vertical assistance structure appeared lightweight for a bridge covering such a hectic port, specialists stated, and did not seem secured by a significant effect barrier.

Tuesday’s occurrence took place prior to 1:30 a.m., when a 948-foot-long freight vessel called Dali lost power as it was leaving Baltimore’s port at a speed of8 knots. After the ship rammed into among the bridge’s assistance piers, the structure started to shatter practically immediately.

Within seconds, the southern and main periods of the bridge started to collapse. The northern period. In 25 seconds, the whole bridge had actually plunged into the Patapsco River. Authorities state 6 members of a building team dealing with the bridge were still unaccounted for since Tuesday afternoon, and other victims might still be found.

A before and after picture of Baltimore’s Francis Scott Bridge after a 948-foot-long freight vessel called Dali rammed into the bridge.

(Image © Planet Labs PBC)

Professionals state the Baltimore collapse does not expose considerable vulnerabilities in the significant bridges near ports throughout California, which has the 2 busiest in the country: the Port of Los Angeles and the Port of Long Beach, which deal with about 40% of U.S. container imports from Asia. The Los Angeles port saw 1,712 vessels show up in 2023.

Robert Dowell, an associate teacher of structural engineering at San Diego State University, stated California’s significant bridges are less at threat of being fallen by errant freight ships since their assistance columns have actually been retrofitted to make them hold up against significant earthquakes.

“If they were seismically retrofitted, they would be enhanced and you would not anticipate as delicate vertical members as what you saw supporting the Baltimore bridge,” Dowell stated.

California’s significant bridges generally have strong assistances and considerable bumpers that use the bridge security from a crash, Dowell stated.

The Francis Scott Key Bridge, Dowell stated, appeared susceptible for a structure in such an essential shipping center. Its assistance pier did not appear to have a big sufficient bumper surrounding it, he stated, and the pier itself was not one strong structure, however comprised of numerous vertical members. It appears from zoomed-in video of the bridge collapse that the ship effect triggered the failure of among these vertical members initially, straining the remainder of the vertical members at the one pier, leading to the subsequent total collapse of the primary period.

Such a vertical assistance, Dowell stated, was “a bit uncommon to be so delicate when big ships are coming through the shipping channel.” Even for such a delicate pier, if an appropriate bumper was offered around the base of the pier, it would have secured the pier from direct effect and conserved the bridge, he stated.

“You would believe, if that’s where the big ships are expected to go,

» …
Learn more